Some long-term Carhartt buyers report poor quality and fit on certain pieces, citing seams coming open, large holes after a few months of wear, and easy dye transfer.
SourceColumn review
Carhartt Multicolor Shorts Collection: Straight-Leg, Drawstring-Closed Work Shorts in Black and Khaki
Footwear and apparel editor specializing in shoes, everyday clothing, jerseys, slippers, socks, and underwear, with a practical focus on sizing, fit, materials, construction, comfort cues, durability, and visible QC consistency. · Updated 2026-09-26
QC photos by style
Explore reference photos for individual styles from this source listing.
View QC PhotosQuick verdict
A polyester-blend, medium-stretch straight short with a drawstring closure, sold in M–XXL and labeled for summer. Because buyer evidence is thin and split, treat sizing as the open question rather than the quality claim. Ask your agent for flat waist and inseam measurements, and confirm which fabric the seller is shipping.
Reference price
$24.93 USD $26.82Final item price, service fees and international shipping are confirmed on the shopping agent's website.
Pros
- · Catalog states medium stretch and a straight, mid-rise cut with a drawstring closure — a waistband that adjusts without a belt
- · Two solid colorways (black, khaki) in a letter-print, washed-finish basic style
- · Catalog lists a deformation-resistant material function and summer suitability, with sizes M through XXL
- · Stated 2CM measurement tolerance gives a concrete number to compare against a seller-supplied measurement
Cons
- · Size reports for Carhartt garments conflict: some describe a roomy waist, others say pieces measure smaller than the tag (a size 32 reported closer to 29)
- · Some long-term Carhartt buyers report seams opening, holes after a few months, and dye transfer on certain pieces
- · Closed drawstring waist means no belt loops to correct a loose fit
Fit notes
Carhartt size reports conflict: one set describes a roomy waist and hip and suggests your usual jeans waist or sizing down, another reports garments measuring well below the tag. Sizes run M–XXL with a stated 2CM tolerance. Get the flat waist measurement from the seller and compare it to shorts you already own.
Buy if
You want a basic straight-cut, mid-rise work short in black or khaki with a drawstring waist, medium stretch, and a washed finish for daily summer wear — and you are willing to confirm actual measurements with the seller before ordering.
Skip if
You need a fixed, verified size match without measuring, or you require a belted waistband. The available Carhartt sizing reports point in opposite directions, so a buyer unwilling to check measurements first is the wrong fit for this listing.
Ready to order?
Carhartt pants in polyester with stretch fabric
Reference $24.93 USD · confirm fees on Kakobuy
Buying FAQ
Common questions
Does the buyer evidence agree on how these shorts fit?⌄
No. One set of Carhartt shorts discussion pages describes a loose waist and hip and suggests sizing down for a closer fit, while another buyer report says garments measure smaller than the tag. Both directions are on record, so no single size recommendation holds.
What fabric should I expect?⌄
The listing is inconsistent: it names polyester as the main fabric and the fabric name, but also lists cotton under fabric. Confirm with the seller which fiber the shorts you are ordering actually use.
Are the reported quality complaints specific to this item?⌄
No. The seam, hole, and dye-transfer reports come from general Carhartt discussion, not from this listing's buyers, so they flag what to inspect on arrival rather than a confirmed fault here.
What should I check before ordering?⌄
Ask the seller for the flat waist and inseam measurements and compare them to a short you already own, then confirm the fiber content and the drawstring closure, since those are the points the listing leaves ambiguous.
Evidence
Public notes used
Chinese review topic pages for Carhartt WIP-style cargo shorts report a loose, roomy cut at the waist and hip, advising buyers to pick their usual jeans waist size or size down if they want a closer fit.
SourceBuyers complain that Carhartt garment sizing runs small relative to the label — one widely discussed post reports a piece tagged size 32 measuring closer to a 29, and commenters say they size up one to two sizes in Carhartt.
SourceColumn notes are compiled from catalog data and public discussions where available. Purchase links may include promotion parameters. See the column guide.
Community
Customer Reviews
No approved reviews yet.
Keep browsing
Related reviews
Column · Miles Chen — Footwear & Apparel Editor
Carhartt Multicolor Shorts: Cotton Terry, Relaxed Cut, Embroidered Detail
Column · Miles Chen — Footwear & Apparel Editor
Carhartt Cargo Pants Collection: Cotton Cargos in a Very Wide Color Range
Column · Miles Chen — Footwear & Apparel Editor
Carhartt Brown Cargo Pants in a Washed Cotton Straight Leg
Column · Rina Park — Fashion Accessories Editor
Carhartt Drawstring Backpack in Oxford Cloth, Five Colorways
Column · Miles Chen — Footwear & Apparel Editor
Carhartt Embroidered Script Tee Collection — Loose-Fit Cotton Jersey in Seven Colors
Pair with
Also worth checking
Column · Rina Park — Fashion Accessories Editor
Carhartt Drawstring Backpack in Oxford Cloth, Five Colorways
Column · Miles Chen — Footwear & Apparel Editor
Carhartt Embroidered Script Tee Collection — Loose-Fit Cotton Jersey in Seven Colors
Reference
$24.93